Friday, 15 May 2009

Science vs. Free Will, Again

The question of whether we have "free will" has kept philosophers occupied for at least 2000 years. Wouldn't it be nice if science came along and sorted the whole thing out?
That's the reason why so many people are excited about reports like the one just published in Science, Movement Intention After Parietal Cortex Stimulation in Humans. The report itself is extremely straightforward. The authors, a team of French neurosurgeons, used electrodes to stimulate various points on the surface of the brains of seven patients. The patients were all suffering from brain tumours in various places, and they were undergoing surgery to remove them. As often happens, the authors decided to try to squeeze a little research out of the procedure as well.

The authors stimulated points in various areas of the brain, but the most interesting results came from the premotor cortex (the blue area on the picture above) and the posterior parietal cortex (red and yellow).

When certain points on the premotor cortex were stimulated, the patients moved. But they were not aware that they had done so. For example:
...during stimulation patient PM1 exhibited a large multijoint movement involving flexion of the left wrist, fingers, and elbow ... He did not spontaneously comment on this, and when asked whether he had felt a movement he responded negatively.
That's pretty interesting in itself, but even more so is what happened when the posterior parietal cortex got zapped. Stimulation here produced a desire or intention to move, although no movement actually occured:
Stimulation of all these sites produced a pure intention, that is, a felt desire to move without any overt movement being produced... Without prompting by the examiner, all three patients spontaneously used terms such as “will,” “desire,” and “wanting to,” which convey the voluntary character of the movement intention and its attribution to an internal source, that is, located within the self.
And as if that wasn't enough philosophically-provocative fun, high intensity stimulation of the same area made the patients believe that they had in fact moved, although they didn't move a muscle:
[with higher electrode currents] conscious motor intentions were replaced by a sensation that a movement had been accomplished [but] no actual movement was observed. Thus, these patients experienced awareness of an illusory movement. For example, patient PP3 reported after low-intensity stimulation of one site (5 mA, 4 s; site a in Fig. 1), “I felt a desire to lick my lips” and at a higher intensity (8 mA, 4 s), “I moved my mouth, I talked, what did I say?”
Wow. What are we to make of all this?

A while back I wrote about Wilder Penfield's idea of "double conciousness" which Christian neurosurgeon Michael Egnor described approvingly as
Penfield found that he could invoke all sorts of things- movements, sensations, memories. But in every instance (hundreds of thousands of individual stimulations- in different locations in each patient- during his career), the patients were aware that the stimulation was being done to them, but not by them. There was a part of the mind that was independent of brain stimulation and that constituted a part of subjective experience that Penfield was not able to manipulate with his surgery.

Penfield called this "double consciousness", meaning that there was a part of subjective experience that he could invoke or modify materially, and a different part that was immune to such manipulation.
So Penfield, one of the great pioneers of 20th century neuroscience, claimed that stimulation of the brain could never produce desires or intentions which were experienced as the subject's "own". The person whose brain you were stimulating always felt that whatever happened to them came from outside.

But this French report directly contradicts that. We can only speculate as to why. It could be that Penfield just never hit the right spot, but this seems extremely unlikely, as he did a lot of stimulating over the course of his career. A cynic might ask whether Penfield did observe similar phenomena and just never reported them, but if we're going to go down that road, it's equally likely that these neurosurgeons just made it all up. Fortunately, any neurosurgeon should be able to try to replicate these results with a few prods of an electrode, so it shouldn't take long before the truth becomes clearer.

If these present results hold up, they'll certainly suggest some interesting ideas about the organisation of the brain - such as that the perception of movement depends upon the neurones encoding the intention to move rather than those involved in producing the actual motor act.

It would also be interesting to find out what happens when you simulataneously stimulate the premotor spot which makes your arm move, and the posterior parietal spot which makes you want to move your arm. Would that make you want to move your arm - and do so? If so, that would suggest that something very similar to that is going on whenever we do anything. What is life, but wanting to move, and moving?

But whether that's true or not, intentions (and everything else) are still something that happens in the brain, and the brain is a material object subject to the laws of physics. Neuroscience can tell us how exactly it all fits together, but at the end of the day, it's all a bunch of cells. Free will, in other words, appears to be in trouble, whatever the details of the brain's mechanisms happen to be.

ResearchBlogging.orgDesmurget, M., Reilly, K., Richard, N., Szathmari, A., Mottolese, C., & Sirigu, A. (2009). Movement Intention After Parietal Cortex Stimulation in Humans Science, 324 (5928), 811-813 DOI: 10.1126/science.1169896

18 comments:

Nusubito said...

This is indeed damning, but will likely be shrugged off by philosophers of mind who have a need for free will in their worldview.

After all, once it was shown that a physical object, the brain, was the source of our consciousness, and its removal ended our consciousness, there was never any reason to suppose the matter in our brain behaved differently than matter anywhere else.

That said, I love this experiment, and I'm glad you posted it. I will have to come here more often.

That's not my name! said...

Hmmm...can I go 50/50?

Or should I phone a friend?

Okay, if the thumb screws are being turned I choose free will.

Science doesn't motivate me to get out of bed in the morning but my will ensures (most days) that I do.

pj said...

I'd just point out - as has been done by many others - that the tension between 'free will' and 'determinism' illustrates a question that is ill posed.

Neuroskeptic said...

Totally agree, but that's a bit of a long story and I didn't want to go into that in this post...

Tony said...

Free will is the same as determinism

Michael J said...

This stuff makes my head spin. My first thought is what triggers the posterior parietal cortex normally? I'm a staunch materialist but it is easy to fall in the trap of imagining a "me" sitting there pushing the controls.

Neuroskeptic said...

What triggers the parietal? That's a very good question. The least freaky answer would be that the parietal is what controls everything else - because that would mean that concious intentions are what drive our actions. In which case the "self" would reside in the parietal cortex.

But I very much doubt it works like that. The brain is rarely so simple.

pj said...

If we keep asking 'what triggers X' we're going to fall into an infinite regress - it seems rather more likely that the parietal responds to sensory input as well as projections back from other cortical regions.

The brain is not a linear series of relays.

Nigel said...

Nusubito said...
This is indeed damning, but will likely be shrugged off by philosophers of mind who have a need for free will in their worldview.
Have you ever actually read any philosophy? Can you name any living philosopher likely to respond in such a way?

NeuroPsych said...

I have not read the study yet, but some of what you reported contradicts "conventional wisdom" in the field. The pre-motor cortex usually is activated when people "think" or "plan" a motor movement. It's connections run to the basal ganglia, which has a role with initiation. That it produced movement without conscious awareness is interesting; however, in the picture, the blue area actually is the primary motor cortex (which receives input from the basal ganglia), the pre-motor cortex is located more anteriorly.

The parietal lobe lobe has a role in spatial movement (e.g., parietal reach area). That it produced the "will" (i.e., supposed role of pre-motor area) to initiate movement is also interesting.

The last finding is the only one that makes sense. The sensation of movement obviously being connected the the somatosensory cortex.

It's endlessly fascinating how difficult the brain is to make consistent sense of.

Neuroskeptic said...

Hmmm. They say the blue area is BA6, i.e. premotor cortex. And the points they stimulate are at the anterior edge of that area.

it looks too anterior to be primary motor to me...

Owlie said...

zapping someone's brain with electricity doesn't prove determinism. that's like lifting somebody's arm with your own and saying "look, he's doing it automatically, without free will!" of course he is. you're forcing him to.

Unknown said...

"jack said...

zapping someone's brain with electricity doesn't prove determinism. that's like lifting somebody's arm with your own and saying "look, he's doing it automatically, without free will!" of course he is. you're forcing him to."
[i don't know html]
I say:
if this dude didn't "zap" their brains during this experiment, some other part of their brain would normally "zap" that bit, forcing the person to feel as if they are moving anyhow, and who's to say YOU control that bit that is forcing you to feel like you are doing things like moving. personally, i think free will is a psychological embellishment of our roles in existence.

Anonymous said...

I don't think the question of whether we have free will is metaphysical. I think it is a scientific one, but impossible to answer. If you have the time and patience please read the following argument:
We have a question, does free will exist or not?
We have two answers, with no possible third option:
Yes, or no.



1) If YES, then that means that either the particles (atoms and molecules) of the human brain have the spectacular behavior of defying laws of physics in order to lead to events which ultimately result in the satisfaction of the brain-owner, OR that the laws of physics themselves are not deterministic and they do leave a window open for random events to happen.


2) If the answer is NO, then what that means is that the particles of the human brain have to obey a set formula all the time, no exceptions made, ever.



A) but if "1" is true then it is impossible to confine the defiance of matter or the randomness of laws of physics to the spatial boundaries of the human brain. It must happen everywhere. Particles must defy laws of physics everywhere. Therefore any attempt to devise an experiment to measure how they behave will ultimately fail.



B) and if "2" is true, then it is impossible for a subset of particles to make an absolutely accurate measurement of the whole set, i.e. it is impossible for human brains, a subset, to devise an experiment that would produce an accurate measurement of the whole system. And if they cannot do that, then they simply can never reach a definite answer.

Therefore it is impossible to determine whether we have free will or not.


Alright then, now I'm off to the pub :)

Timothy Chow said...

The fact that scientists have made such great progress in understanding the brain suggests that we might be able to carry out in the laboratory an old philosophical game called Newcomb's paradox.

In Newcomb's paradox, there are two boxes, Box A and Box B. Box A visibly contains $100 (for example). Box B is opaque and contains either $0 or $200 (the way in which the contents of Box B will be determined will be explained shortly).

There is a clock that counts down to zero. As soon as the clock shows zero, the subject must press one of two buttons—Button 1 or Button 2. If the subject presses Button 1, then the subject earns the contents of both Box A and Box B (i.e., either $100 or $300 depending on what happens to be in Box B). If the subject presses Button 2, then the subject earns the contents of Box B only, and forgoes the $100 in Box A. If the subject does not press either button (or presses both buttons) before the deadline passes, then the subject gets nothing.

Now for the twist. Whether Box B contains $0 or $200 is decided by a machine that, at the instant the clock shows zero, puts $0 into Box B if it predicts that the subject will press Button 1, and puts $200 into Box B if it predicts that the subject will press Button 2.

The tricky part of the setup is to adjust the length of the deadline. It must be long enough that the subject has the impression that he or she is able to make a decision after the clock shows zero, but it must be short enough so that the machine can reliably predict which button the subject is about to press.

I believe that this experiment would be a very powerful contribution to our understanding of voluntary action, and judging from how many papers have been published on Newcomb's paradox, I'm sure it would be very interesting to philosophers. I tried emailing Patrick Haggard, urging him to perform this experiment, but since I'm a nobody, not surprisingly he ignored my email. If anyone reading this comment knows a scientist who might perform this experiment, I encourage you to pass the idea along.

Anonymous said...

Just a little inconsistency on this articles part that I could hope be clarified. Initially it says they conducted the experiments on seven patients but then it only refers to three: "all three patients spontaneously used terms such as “will,” “desire,” and “wanting to,”"

What about the other four?

Neuroskeptic said...

Good question, anon. That's something I should have made more clear.

Only three of the patients were stimulated in the posterior regions, and of those three, all experienced desires to move.

"For the three patients with postcentral tumors, nine responsive sites were found in BAs 39 and 40 (Fig. 1). Stimulation of all these sites produced a pure intention, that is, a felt desire to move without any overt movement being produced or EMG activity recorded in the concerned muscles..."

These were the three patients with tumors near this region ("postcentral" means posterior).

The other four patients had tumors in a more anterior (frontal) region, and they were stimulated in that area, which caused actual movement without awareness.

For each patient, the electrical stimulation took place near the tumor. This makes sense because in surgery you will only need to stimulate the areas near the surgical site.

Anonymous said...

This is pretty interesting, but the belief that free will can be scientifically examined is, I believe, misguided. Whatever the outcome of an experiment is, it can be attributed to some deterministic event -- observed (oh look readiness potential) or not (the brain is so complex lolol).