Subscribe Now!

Saturday, 27 November 2010

The Town That Went Mad

Pont St. Esprit is a small town in southern France. In 1951 it became famous as the site of one of the most mysterious medical outbreaks of modern times.

As Dr's Gabbai, Lisbonne and Pourquier wrote to the British Medical Journal, 15 days after the "incident":
The first symptoms appeared after a latent period of 6 to 48 hours. In this first phase, the symptoms were generalized, and consisted in a depressive state with anguish and slight agitation.

After some hours the symptoms became more clearly defined, and most of the patients presented with digestive disturbances... Disturbances of the autonomic nervous system accompanied the digestive disorders-gusts of warmth, followed by the impression of "cold waves", with intense sweating crises. We also noted frequent excessive salivation.

The patients were pale and often showed a regular bradycardia (40 to 50 beats a minute), with weakness of the pulse. The heart sounds were rather muffled; the extremities were cold... Thereafter a constant symptom appeared - insomnia lasting several days... A state of giddiness persisted, accompanied by abundant sweating and a disagreeable odour. The special odour struck the patient and his attendants.
In most patients, these symptoms, including the total insomnia, persisted for several days. In some of the patients, these symptoms progressed to full-blown psychosis:
Logorrhoea [speaking a lot], psychomotor agitation, and absolute insomnia always presaged the appearance of mental disorders. Towards evening visual hallucinations appeared, recalling those of alcoholism. The particular themes were visions of animals and of flames. All these visions were fleeting and variable.

In many of the patients they were followed by dreamy delirium. The delirium seemed to be systematized, with animal hallucinations and self-accusation, and it was sometimes mystical or macabre. In some cases terrifying visions were followed by fugues, and two patients even threw themselves out of windows... Every attempt at restraint increased the agitation.

In severe cases muscular spasms appeared, recalling those of tetanus, but seeming to be less sustained and less painful... The duration of these periods of delirium was very varied. They lasted several hours in some patients, in others they still persist.
In total, about 150 people suffered some symptoms. About 25 severe cases developed the "delirium". 4 people died "in muscular spasm and in a state of cardiovascular collapse"; three of these were old and in poor health, but one was a healthy 25-year-old man.

At first, the cause was assumed to be ergotism - poisoning caused by chemicals produced by a fungus which can infect grain crops. Contaminated bread was, therefore, thought to be responsible. Ergotism produces symptoms similar to those reported at Pont St. Esprit, including hallucinations, because some of the toxins are chemically related to LSD.

However, there have been other theories. Some (including Albert Hofmann, the inventor of LSD) attribute the poisoning to pesticides containing mercury, or to the flour bleaching agent nitrogen trichloride.

More recently, journalist Hank Albarelli claimed that it was in fact a CIA experiment to test out the effects of LSD as a chemical weapon, though this is disputed. What really happened is, in other words, still a mystery.

Link: The Crazies (2010) is a movie about a remarkably similar outbreak of mass insanity in a small town.

ResearchBlogging.orgGABBAI, LISBONNE, & POURQUIER (1951). Ergot poisoning at Pont St. Esprit. British medical journal, 2 (4732), 650-1 PMID: 14869677

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

Whoring for readership by stirring conspiracy theories?
Do you know that 9/11 is still a good one?
[ROFLMAO the captcha is "tastes"!!!]

SustainableFamilies said...

I went through something exactly like this. The taste, and smell. Hmmm. I wonder what the hell happened to me, because honestly the spontenaity of the event I went through (that sparked a few weeks of madness) has still left me curious. Unfortunately because I told them I felt crazy, there were no medical tests done. (Well that and I was screaming incessantly in the hospital so they gave up with trying to get me in a gown and do some blood work and the like and shuffled me to the mental health unit as I requested). There were no lesions in my brain, I got that checked afterward because the profound taste of blood and metal was so intense and prolongued. Temporal lobe eplipsy was considered but the eeg showed abnormal parietal lobe activity and not temporal lobe activity.

Dammit why does it take so many years and so much work to become a neurologist, just so I can figure out what the hell was up with that? Suck.

Neuroskeptic said...

Anonymous: If I were whoring for readers I'd have put the conspiracy theory in the title of the post and called it: "Did the CIA send a town mad?"

But because I think it's very unlikely, I didn't.

However, it's not impossible. The CIA did do lots of experiments with LSD. I admit that it's a classic conspiracy theory with scant evidence but it's not quite at the level of 9/11 nonsense.

veri said...

It was probably the French or the Germans. They did horrendous medical experiments too. The French probably still do in the banlieues or cites.

SF, that must've been traumatic. Maybe it was a toxic shock through the eyes so the EEG didn't detect it. I'm surprised the doc didn't immediately run blood tests. I hope you're ok.

veri said...

I don't see this as a conspiracy. Back then it was war, anything went. Now they have monkeys, prisoners and detention centres shrouded in red tape. Access to remote communities, developing countries, CDF etc. thanks to rigorous bilateral treaties, signatories to the UN. I don't think intentions have changed, just the modus operandi.

Anonymous said...

veri you should know better: it's obviously the D-E-V-I-L...

veri said...

Those symptoms don't look to follow the pattern of a demonic possession. If it was demonic it should easily be purged with a standard excorcism. From what I recall there was a demonic outbreak in France centuries? or so earlier.. some books about it:

Demonic Possession and Exorcism: In Early Modern France - Sarah Ferber

http://www.amazon.com/Demonic-Possession-Exorcism-Modern-France/dp/0415212650

Unclean Spirits: Possession and Exorcism in France and England in the Late Sixteenth and Early Seventeenth Centuries -
Daniel Pickering Walker

http://www.amazon.com/Unclean-Spirits-Possession-Sixteenth-Seventeenth/dp/081227797X

Exorcism and Enlightenment: Johann Joseph Gassner and the demons of eighteenth-century Germany - H. C. Erik Midelfort

http://books.google.com.au/books?id=B9bg3g0T2HAC&dq=Exorcism+and+Enlightenment+:+Johann+Joseph+Gassner+and+the+demons+of+eighteenth-century+Germany+/+H.C.+Erik+Midelfort.&source=bl&ots=-baQZnogQA&sig=yVDerq99TCtsuHjQmW0r2kZrzQM&hl=en&ei=wPbxTJatHYmycJSE3LAK&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CBgQ6AEwAA

Anonymous said...

veri: WWII ended in 1945. This happened in 1951. This was not part of "war."

veri said...

When the iron curtain fell with the Cold War.. what did you think I was talking about? They were shooting each other in WWI&II why would they need to poison each other? The nuclear stalemates meant no more full blown weapon combat, instead horrendous medical experiments targeting specific individuals, populations, poisoning, discrete/covert operations against the enemy. The Berlin Wall fell in 1989.

Quote from The Plutonium Files: America's Secret Medical Experiments in the Cold War - Eileen Welzome

As World War II reached its climax, the U.S. push to create an atomic bomb spawned an industry the size of General Motors almost overnight. But a little-understood human dilemma quickly arose: How was all the radiation involved in building and testing the bomb going to affect the countless researchers, soldiers, and civilians exposed to it? Government scientists scrambled to find out, fearing cancer outbreaks and worse, but in their urgency conducted classified experiments that bordered on the horrific: MIT researchers fed radioactive oatmeal to residents of a state boys' school outside Boston; prisoners in Washington and Oregon were subjected to crippling blasts of direct radiation; and patients with terminal illnesses (or so it was hoped) were secretly injected with large doses of plutonium--survivors were surreptitiously monitored for years afterward.

Roger bigod said...

What is the "latent period" they mention? It implies a time duration from an initiating event. But if they know the time of the event, they would know what it was.

Neuroskeptic said...

Roger Bigod: Everyone at the time attributed it to a batch of bread. I'd imagine that "Zero Hour" was when the freshly baked bread went on sale.

Almost everyone since has agreed that the bread was the cause, the disagreement is over what the toxin in the bread was.

Elijah Gregory said...

Pronounced brachycardia is a common side-effect of psilocybe mushrooms. Some users report the lack of a pulse during their experience. Digestive disturbance is also the most common presenting symptom.

I think it is more likely the toxin came from a bad batch of mushrooms, or some other fungus more closely related to Psilocybe than LSD.

(Oh yeah, and also, isn't it OK for the editor of a major journal to change phrases like "very varied" to "quite varied"?)

Roger Bigod said...

Thanks for the explanation.

It clearly wasn't LSD, judging from the symptoms and time course. IIRC, the odious CIA experiments didn't get underway until t he late 50's, and there's no reason for them to have chosen an obscure French village.

Leon said...

The 1951 events in Pont St. Esprit are certainly some of the most fascinating and puzzling of the twentieth century. However, I don't agree that mercury poisoning or nitrogen trichloride are reasonable suspects. There was no evidence of the renal impairment usually caused by mercury, and to my knowledge no human cases of psychosis, hallucinations, and peripheral ischemia caused by NCl3 have ever been reported.