Sunday, 13 February 2011

The Mystery of Stiff Person Syndrome

"Stiff Person Syndrome" (SPS) is a rare neurological disease with a silly name but serious symptoms.

Not in fact a disorder caused by an overdose of Viagra, the defining feature of SPS is uncontrollable muscle rigidity, which comes and goes in bouts, but generally gets worse over time. However, other symptoms are seen including depression, anxiety, and other neurological features such as cerebellar ataxia.

What causes SPS? Well, it's been known for over 20 years that most SPS patients have antibodies against the enzyme GAD65, which is required for the production of GABA, the main inhibitory neurotransmitter in the brain. The body shouldn't be producing antibodies against its own proteins, but unfortunately this does happen quite often, for various reasons, and the result is autoimmune diseases.

So this all seems to make sense. We know that GABA causes muscle relaxation by reducing the brain's input to the muscles. This is why GABA drugs like Valium are muscle-relaxants, and it's part of the reason why drunk people tend to stagger around.

This also explains the anxiety symptoms, because Valium and beer make you less anxious, while drugs that block GABA cause panic attacks. Anti-GAD65 antibodies block GAD, so less GABA gets made. So SPS is autoimmunity against GAD65. Mystery solved?

Not quite. Anti-GAD65 antibodies are also seen in most people with Type I diabetes, but the vast majority of diabetics luckily don't suffer SPS. Mystery remains.

Two studies just out investigated exactly what the antibodies produced by SPS patients do. Geis et al purified the antibodies from a 53 year old woman with SPS and serious anxiety, and injected them into the brains of some rats.

The rats became very anxious. Here's what the cowardly critters did in a standard rodent anxiety test: they avoided the open spaces, which are naturally scary to rodents, who prefer dark, enclosed places:

This was associated with reduced GABA production.

Meanwhile Manto et al found that anti-GAD65 antibodies from another patient with SPS caused very different effects in rat brains compared to the antibodies derived from a patient with autoimmune cerebellar ataxia, but no SPS symptoms. They also found that two kinds of off-the-shelf anti-GAD65 antibodies commonly used in research had different effects as well.

Taken together this all suggests that SPS is caused by anti-GAD65 antibodies, but they have to be a particular type. Different antibodies cause different symptoms even though they all bind to GAD65.

Presumably this is because it's a big protein, and antibodies could bind to any part of it. Only ones that block the "business end" - the part which actually catalyzes the formation of GABA - will cause problems. A bit like how if you get shot in the heart, that's the end of you, but get shot in the foot and it probably won't be.


ResearchBlogging.orgGeis, C., et al. (2011). Human Stiff-Person Syndrome IgG Induces Anxious Behavior in Rats PLoS ONE, 6 (2) DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0016775

Manto MU, Hampe CS, Rogemond V, & Honnorat J (2011). Respective implications of glutamate decarboxylase antibodies in stiff person syndrome and cerebellar ataxia. Orphanet journal of rare diseases, 6 (1) PMID: 21294897

6 comments:

Eolirin said...

Does this suggest that it's possible that *other* ways of blocking GABA production could also cause the same or similar results?

Aleksander Więckowski said...

This comment will be unrelated to this post, but I see no other way to contact you - everywhere on the Internet they are currently writing about this boy, Chase Britton, who lives quite normally without his cerebellum and pons:
http://www.aolnews.com/2011/02/12/chase-britton-boy-without-a-cerebellum-baffles-doctors/
Of course, this great opportunity for all kinds of people to deny neuroscience/physicalism... I would be very grateful if you could comment on this.

Neuroskeptic said...

Hey, thanks, I hadn't seen that, will definately take a look.

P.S. You can email me at n....skeptic@googlemail by the way.

Neuroskeptic said...

P.S. Obviously it's not literally that, it's neuroskeptic@ , that's to stop spammers.

veri said...

Big man syndrome! Posture of African politicians and dictators.

Ur.. this entry may interest you:

http://theness.com/neurologicablog/?p=2830

Debra A. Richardson said...

As a person having SPS for 22 years, I find your opening comment offensive & demeaning to those of us who live/die with this vicious disorder. Misunderstanding of SPS delays an accurate diagnosis for years along with possible benefit from medication/treatment.

I do have a personal website with reputable medical info for those in the beginning fear of diagnosis.

I also blog. Humor is a vital coping mechanism for me. I express my sense of 'dark' humor in my blog. They are two distinct forums. To begin an informative post about the syndrome with a flippant attempt at humor is...

I live the life.

Debra Richardson